500,000 votes crown Pistacia Vera as Columbus' top dessert spot
Three bakeries and cafes dominate the annual reader survey results released this week.
By Noor Graham ·

Pistacia Vera holds the top spot for desserts in Columbus according to the 2026 ColumBEST list. The ranking comes from a survey where (614) Magazine readers cast nearly 500,000 votes. The publication uses these ballots to rank local businesses across categories ranging from barbecue to bars.
The list covers a wide array of local establishments. Readers determined the results without editorial interference. The voting process concludes with a final ranking of the city's preferred venues for various goods and services.
Pistacia Vera operates in historic German Village. The bakery serves handcrafted croissants, éclairs, tarts, and cookies. It also offers cakes and seasonal confections alongside coffee, tea, and a brunch menu with savory options.
Cheesecake Girl takes the number two position. The business began as a home-based baking hobby before expanding into a full operation. It specializes in made-from-scratch cheesecakes. The menu includes mini cheesecakes, cookie sandwiches filled with cheesecake, and dessert jars.
Chocolate Cafe ranks third on the list. The cafe focuses on chocolate items such as handcrafted truffles and chocolate-covered pretzels. It also serves Buckeyes and specialty desserts. The establishment offers breakfast, brunch, soups, salads, sandwiches, coffee, wine, and cocktails.
The full 2026 ColumBEST results are available in (614) Magazine. Readers can access the complete data online or in print. The publication also releases Stock & Barrel, which features additional local recommendations.






