AARP warns Social Security tax base no longer matches today's economy
A new study argues that the shift in income from wages to capital has reduced the program's ability to fund benefits for retirees.
By Noor Graham ·

A new AARP study released today argues that the funding structure for Social Security has failed to adapt to a forty year shift in the American economy. The organization says this mismatch threatens the stability of benefits for current and future retirees.
The core of the argument rests on how national income is divided. AARP notes that the program was built for a time when a larger share of economic output went directly to workers. Payroll taxes collected on those wages generated more revenue. Today, a greater portion of income flows to capital owners through corporate profits and investment gains. Rich Johnson of AARP described this as a clear shift from workers to capital.
This shift has changed the reach of the Social Security wage cap. The tax is currently set at about $184,000 in annual earnings. Johnson said this cap now covers only about 83 percent of all earnings in the economy. In the past, it covered roughly 90 percent. As more money moves out of the wage bracket and into investment income, the payroll tax base shrinks relative to total economic output.
Lawmakers are currently weighing how to prevent future cuts to benefits. Senator Ron Johnson, a Republican from Wisconsin, urged Congress to pass a law that stops the reduction of benefits. He told seniors to stop fearing the loss of their income. Senator Jeff Merkley, a Democrat from Oregon, emphasized the reliance many seniors have on the program. He noted that for about half of American seniors who receive benefits, the payments account for half to 100 percent of their total income.
Advocates have proposed several fixes to address the funding gap. Some suggest eliminating the wage cap entirely to broaden the tax base. Others propose taxing corporate profits to supplement payroll taxes. Congress is evaluating these options as it considers legislation to protect retiree payments.






