Why Celebrity Beauty Brands Keep Failing, and the New Rules for Those Trying Anyway
As once-hyped lines from Kim Kardashian, Scarlett Johansson and Gwen Stefani disappear, newcomers like Cardi B and Jennifer Lawrence are testing a tougher playbook for star-backed beauty.
By News Media House Staff ·

The celebrity beauty gold rush is littered with casualties. Gwen Stefani's GXVE Beauty is gone, along with Scarlett Johansson's skin care line The Outset and Serena Williams' Wyn Beauty. Kim Kardashian's KKW Beauty and SKKN by Kim have been retired, Blake Lively's Blake Brown Beauty hair care is struggling, and Jennifer Lopez's JLO Beauty has quietly exited Sephora. Even so, Cardi B and Jennifer Lawrence have recently joined the fray.
The incentive is obvious: with production slates threatening to keep shrinking, a stake in a hit brand can be worth far more than a movie deal. The success stories are seductive. Rihanna's Fenty Beauty helped make her a billionaire, Selena Gomez's Rare Beauty has been valued at $2.7 billion, and Hailey Bieber's Rhode sold to e.l.f. Beauty in a deal worth up to $1 billion.
In October, Lawrence launched Mes, pronounced mess, with Arcaea CEO Jasmina Aganovic, drawing buzz and backlash from critics who saw another case of celebrity overreach. The partnership reportedly began after Lawrence watched Aganovic deliver a TED Talk about the future of cosmetics. Aganovic's biotech company develops sustainable cosmetic ingredients and has counted Chanel among its investors; she previously worked at Living Proof and led skin-microbiome brand Mother Dirt. Mes promises great hair without much time or effort under an unbothered beauty philosophy, and Lawrence introduced its hair mask, serum and volume mist on Instagram as a line for nice people who do not leave mean comments. Per her reps, Lawrence was not available to comment.
After years away from social media, Lawrence made her debut Sept. 9, just weeks before launch, and skeptics called it a calculated sales pitch, while others noted she has never been especially known for her hair. Marketing veteran Aliza Licht, author of On Brand, is unsurprised: at this point in the life cycle of celebrity brands, she says, the initial reaction is always going to be the eye roll, because consumers now recognize an engineered marketing narrative dressed up as a personal passion project.
The early industry read on Mes is cautiously optimistic. Clare Hennigan, principal analyst for beauty and consumer goods at Mintel, calls partnering with well-established Arcaea a good move, and sees promise in products like a gel hair mask that can be applied to dry hair and doubles as a styler. "They are solving a pain point of convenience, a key motivator for purchases," she says, adding that shoppers will pay more for anything that makes life a little easier.
Cardi B has shown a keen understanding of community with her Grow-Good hair care line, which followed three years of development, debuted in April and reportedly sold out in less than 35 minutes. Her grassroots strategy focused on neighborhood beauty supply stores, including shops in her native Bronx. "Listen, I know my people because I am my people!" she says. Lisa Motzko Hamilton, a former vice president of merchandising at Ulta Beauty, says brands perform best when the entertainer is showing up and sharing something beyond celebrity status, and The Business of Fashion reports a promising 40 percent return-customer rate for Grow-Good.
Fit between star and product also matters. Lady Gaga's Haus Labs draws on her reputation for artistry, and Gomez built Rare Beauty around youth mental health, with 1 percent of sales going to the Rare Impact Fund. Hennigan cites Jennifer Aniston's LolaVie, launched in 2021 after years of development and since expanded to Ulta and Credo, as a brand that gets it right, given Aniston's decades of culturally famous hairstyles. "I didn't want to simply put my name on something; I wanted to be part of building something that I truly believed in," Aniston says, noting that consumer feedback has driven product changes. She has even extended the line to pet shampoo, with all profits benefiting The Clydeo Fund for animal rescue and rehabilitation.
The failures are instructive. Licht says Johansson's The Outset lacked any historical connection between the star and skin care, while Hennigan says the problem was proof, with efficacy and science not visible to shoppers. JLO Beauty's age-defying glow was hung on a family olive oil secret that online doubters, including a chorus of dermatologists, did not buy, creating a trust problem. Blake Brown Beauty launched at Target with fanfare, but Lively went quiet on social media amid the fallout surrounding It Ends With Us and her legal battle with Justin Baldoni, and sales have reportedly dropped sharply. Distribution counts too: Haus Labs initially launched exclusively on Amazon, a challenging fit for color cosmetics shoppers who want to try shades, before a move to Sephora broadened its audience.
Ultimately, a new line must answer why the world needs it, as Fenty did nearly a decade ago with an inclusive shade range and Rhode did with affordable peptide products. The less glamorous test is staying involved long after launch. Kate Hudson, who co-founded Fabletics in 2013 and watched it reportedly surpass $1 billion in revenue in 2025, says building a business is a long game: "You have to love the process, not just the excitement of launching something." Licht is blunter: most celebrities are not cut out for the daily grind required to build a brand, "and that's why a lot of these lines fail."
Originally published by News Media House
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






