Five States Could Push Popular Vote Compact Past 270-Vote Threshold
Democratic control of Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin positions the interstate agreement to potentially bypass the Electoral College by 2028, though legal and political questions remain.
By Sakura Ellis ·

Democratic leaders in five states are poised to join the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an agreement that would allow participating states to award their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote. If Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin sign the compact, the coalition would control 222 existing electoral votes plus 61 new ones, surpassing the 270 threshold required for the compact to take effect. This outcome would effectively neutralize the Electoral College for future presidential elections.
The compact currently includes 18 states and the District of Columbia. No Republican-led state has joined the agreement. The movement gained momentum following midterm elections in which Democrats secured full control of the five additional states. Proponents argue that the popular vote winner has lost the presidency in recent cycles, making the compact a necessary correction to the current system.
Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to the National Popular Vote organization, stated that he has never been more confident that voters will secure a national popular vote in the 2028 election. He cited Pew polling data showing that 63 percent of American voters support this method of selection. Rosenstiel noted that the compact forces candidates to appeal to a wider audience rather than focusing exclusively on swing states.
Governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have indicated they are open to signing the legislation. However, other state leaders have not yet publicly committed. Democratic Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs, who previously supported the measure, has not recently commented on whether her state’s new legislative majorities should proceed. Her office did not respond to requests for comment before publication.
Legal experts question whether the compact complies with the Constitution’s compact clause, which generally requires congressional consent for interstate agreements. Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, argued that the reform would be better achieved through a constitutional amendment. He warned that forcing electors in one state to follow the tally of another could create tensions among the 51 separate election administrators. Miller noted that a 1969 effort to amend the Constitution to eliminate the Electoral College failed.
John Koza, chairman of the National Popular Vote, countered that a centralized bureaucracy is unnecessary. He stated that current state and federal laws already provide for certified vote counts, and the compact merely requires adding those numbers together. Koza argued that this process avoids the risk of a presidentially appointed commission manipulating results.
The next step involves state legislatures passing the necessary bills. If the five key states sign, the compact will trigger a mechanism to notify all states of the new rule. Opponents, including the group Save Our States, warn that the change will shift politics toward regional divides. The 2028 presidential election will be the first to test the compact if it reaches the required electoral vote total.






