Judge hears bid to unblock Kennedy Center closure
Federal officials argued Thursday that a two-year shutdown for repairs is necessary, while the plaintiff warned that lifting the current court order could invite future mismanagement.
By Rebecca Svoboda ·

The Trump administration asked a federal judge on Thursday to dissolve an order preventing the Kennedy Center from closing for two years of renovation. U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper heard arguments but did not issue a ruling from the bench. The judge, who was appointed by Barack Obama, did not specify a timeline for his decision.
Government attorneys filed documents describing the facility as dangerously dilapidated and decrepit. They cited a partial ceiling collapse in early September as evidence of the building's condition. William Jankowski, a Justice Department attorney, told Cooper that the court should be very, very deferential to the board's choices. Jankowski stated that the board's decisions were reasonable and must stand.
The legal battle began when Rep. Joyce Beatty, a Democrat from Ohio, filed suit last December. She is an ex officio member of the center's board and initially challenged the addition of Trump's name to the building. She later expanded her case to include the planned closure. In May, Cooper blocked the shutdown and ruled that the name change was illegal. He described the board's vote as ill-informed and seemingly preordained.
Nathaniel Zelinsky, Beatty's attorney, warned the court that lifting the injunction now would embolden future breaches and misbehavior by the administration. He described the situation as a monumental breach of fiduciary duty that is ongoing. Zelinsky asked the judge to appoint an independent monitor to oversee operations if the order is dissolved, a move he said is standard trust law.
Beatty's legal team argues that the two-year closure is a Band-Aid for mismanagement. They noted that Congress appropriated roughly $257 million for maintenance last year. Their filing suggests that performing work in phases with partial closures over four years would keep the center open to the public. A center official who consulted with Trump concluded that a total closure is the most cost-effective and efficient path to address infrastructure needs.
The hearing focused on whether the board met its legal obligations before voting to close the main building in August and September. Cooper asked Zelinsky how keeping the injunction in place indefinitely benefits the center and the public. The judge also inquired about his authority to appoint a monitor. The administration seeks to complete the repairs and restore the venue, a key site in the president's effort to mark national landmarks.






