AdvertiseDonate
LatestWellcome Backs Major Study of Britain's Planned Social Media Ban for Children
DetroitToledoClevelandFort WayneColumbusPittsburghBuffaloCincinnati
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Fresh headlines, all day.
Newz Broadcast · 220 W Congress St Floors 2,3,4, Detroit, MI 48226

CFP Committee Faces Criticism Over Alabama and Texas Rankings

Analysis of the latest College Football Playoff rankings highlights perceived inconsistencies in how the committee evaluates team resumes and recent performance.

By News Media House Staff ·

Illustration for: CFP Committee Faces Criticism Over Alabama and Texas Rankings
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The College Football Playoff selection committee has drawn scrutiny for its latest rankings, with particular focus on the positions of Alabama and Texas. Alabama retained the No. 3 spot despite all six SEC opponents it defeated this season losing their games over the weekend. This outcome contrasts sharply with the previous week, when Indiana fell five places under similar circumstances. While Alabama is widely regarded as a strong contender for a playoff berth, the specific placement of the Crimson Tide above Texas has raised questions among analysts.

Texas holds a stronger resume on several metrics, including three wins against top 25 teams compared to Alabama's two. The Longhorns also lead in strength of schedule, strength of record, and game control. Notably, Texas defeated No. 9 Tennessee, a team that beat Alabama, along with No. 14 Ohio State and No. 25 Ole Miss. Despite these advantages, Alabama maintains a higher ranking, largely due to its superior margin of victory. CFP chair Hunter Yurachek explained that the committee prioritized Alabama's consistency, noting their average point spread in conference games is close to 23 points per game. Yurachek stated that this level of consistent play, both across the season and within individual games, served as the primary differentiator for the committee.

Critics argue that relying heavily on the eye test can lead to trouble, as Texas has occasionally struggled to look dominant even in victories, such as their recent win over LSU. Meanwhile, No. 9 Tennessee has a case for ranking above Alabama given its head-to-head victory. However, the committee has kept the two teams in separate pods, effectively avoiding a direct comparison. This decision leaves Tennessee with little room for error in its upcoming game against Lane Kiffin's Tigers, as a loss could trigger significant backlash.

Texas is currently viewed as the most underrated team in the rankings. With two regular season weeks remaining, the Longhorns are ranked No. 5. Given that the committee placed two-loss Alabama ahead of undefeated UCLA at No. 3, there is a compelling argument that Texas should be the highest ranked two-loss team and in line for a bye. Conversely, Ohio State is considered overrated after moving up six spots to the top 14 following a narrow nine-point win over unranked Northwestern. The Buckeyes, missing key players, appear vulnerable despite possessing talented roster players like receiver Jeremiah Smith.

Indiana also remains underrated in the eyes of many observers. After dropping from No. 4 to No. 9 the previous week, the Hoosiers climbed only one spot despite a decisive 27-13 victory over No. 18 USC. Head coach Curt Cignetti had previously used social media to highlight his team's ranking, a move that may not have pleased the committee. While Indiana's weak non-conference schedule is a factor, their only loss was to a full-strength Ohio State team, and their defensive prowess suggests they are capable of championship contention.

The rankings have also drawn fire for keeping four-loss SEC teams in the top 25. South Carolina, currently at No. 21, is a prime example, having lost 34-6 to Arkansas. Similar arguments apply to Oklahoma, Florida, and Ole Miss. This inclusion provides benefits to other teams; for instance, South Carolina's presence gives Alabama another win over a ranked team, aiding the committee's justification for the Crimson Tide's top four position. Similarly, Ole Miss at No. 25 benefits Texas. The situation frustrates Big Ten and Group of Six teams, such as Illinois, Northwestern, Liberty, and Memphis, which have yet to secure a spot in the rankings.

Originally published by News Media House

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Newz Broadcast in your inboxFresh headlines, all day. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Newz Broadcast in your inboxFresh headlines, all day. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.