Hoffman Family of Companies hit with state antitrust suit
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel alleges the firm used its control of both major ferry services to raise fares and eliminate discounts.
By Noor Graham ·

Travelers heading to Mackinac Island may face higher costs and fewer options as a result of a lawsuit filed on Thursday by the Michigan Attorney General's office. The state is suing the Hoffman Family of Companies, alleging that its ownership of both major ferry operators created a monopoly that harmed consumers and local workers.
The legal action targets Hoffman and its affiliated entities, which hold stakes in Shepler's Ferry and the Mackinac Island Ferry Company. Nessel contends that these acquisitions granted Hoffman unlawful control over two essential markets: ferry service and long-term parking. The office argues this power allowed the company to push ferry fares above competitive levels while imposing new charges on services that were previously free.
Specific complaints in the filing include the elimination of discounts and passes that island residents and workers relied upon for daily travel. The state also points to new fees for parking that Hoffman began charging after acquiring the property. According to the lawsuit, these changes have removed consumer choice from a market that serves nearly all visitors to the island.
Hoffman acquired the Mackinac Island Ferry Company in 2024, a deal that included docks in Mackinaw City, St. Ignace, and on the island itself, along with land parcels, buildings, and parking spaces. A release from that year stated the acquisition made Hoffman the largest owner of real estate in the area and an employer of 500 people in the Mackinac region. Nessel argues that this consolidation allowed the firm to dominate the transportation sector.
Mackinac Island Mayor Margaret Doud supported the suit in a statement distributed by the Attorney General's office. She noted that over 1.5 million people visit the island annually, many of them Michigan families, and that more than 80% of the land belongs to the state as the Mackinac Island State Historic Parks. Doud said the state is acting on behalf of the public. John Sellek, a spokesperson for the Fair Access to Mackinac Island Coalition, also praised Nessel for using her office's powers to support consumers.
The lawsuit seeks a court order to reopen the markets to competition. It asks a judge to require Hoffman to divest its interest in the ferry services. The goal, according to the filing, is to ensure fair market conditions for residents, businesses, and visitors by ending the alleged monopoly.






