CPS Emails Blame Improper Restraints for 7-Year-Old's Death on School Bus
Superintendent Shauna Murphy wrote that a driver and monitor failed to secure Ngone Talla in her wheelchair, leading to positional asphyxiation.
By Rebecca Svoboda ·

Seven minutes passed between the time a family in Cincinnati’s Northside neighborhood called 911 and the moment emergency crews arrived at their home. By then, Ngone Talla, a seven-year-old student at Roselawn Condon School, had already been pronounced dead at the scene.
The death occurred on September 16, 2026. The Hamilton County Coroner’s Office ruled the manner of death accidental. The cause was identified as positional asphyxiation. Ngone, who was nonverbal and used a wheelchair, was riding a school bus operated by First Student.
Emails provided to WCPO 9 reveal the internal findings of the Cincinnati Public Schools district. Superintendent Shauna Murphy emailed the school board at 8:39 p.m. on the day of the incident. Murphy stated that she spoke with John Keening from First Student. Keening told her that the bus driver and the monitor on duty did not strap the child appropriately. Murphy wrote that this failure caused Ngone’s death.
The autopsy report provides the physical details of the incident. Ngone was secured in a five-point seat belt restraint system attached to her wheelchair. The report notes that Ngone moved her arms and legs, a symptom of her developmental disabilities. During this movement, her body slipped off the wheelchair seat. The seat belt and restraint system then compressed her right neck and chin. This compression led to rapid asphyxiation and a loss of consciousness.
The family’s account of the timeline adds context to the coroner’s findings. Ngone’s father, Abdoula Talla, said the bus arrived at their Colerain Avenue home shortly before 5 p.m. The vehicle sat outside for ten to fifteen minutes before family members were asked to board. Ngone’s twelve-year-old sister, Marema Talla, found her sister motionless in the wheelchair. Marema said she checked for a pulse and noticed Ngone was not breathing. Abdoula called 911 at approximately 5:03 p.m. Dispatch records show crews were sent to the address at 5:05 p.m. for a child in possible cardiac arrest.
The autopsy report mentions a delay in care before emergency services were contacted. Abdoula believes someone aboard the bus should have called for help earlier if they realized Ngone was in distress. He also noted that the monitor on the bus that day was a person his family had never seen. The assistant who normally rode with Ngone was absent. Abdoula has asked CPS to confirm if this employee was new or a substitute.
First Student has said it is fully cooperating with local authorities and the school district. Cincinnati Police have not filed criminal charges against the driver or the monitor. The department has not indicated whether it suspects criminal wrongdoing. The bus’s video file was preserved and given to police.
Carla Leader, an Ohio attorney specializing in education law, noted that the identity of the monitor is important. The answer could matter depending on what Ngone’s Individualized Education Program required. WCPO does not know if the IEP called for a specific aide or what training the employees on the bus received.






